- That's my memory as well. I also don't remember any cognitive dissonance
- between Poitras' and Greenwald's answers to Snowden's question about how
- much background to go into. The film doesn't portray a lot of daylight
- between Snowden and Greenwald in what they want to do, really.
- But that's what you should expect from the movie, I think, given a) how
- close Poitras and Greenwald are, and b) that the movie is clearly meant to
- tell Snowden's story and show his motives and impact, not amplify any drama
- between the people involved.
- The movie didn't cover, for example, Greenwald misleading the entire world
- on why David Miranda was detained at the Heathrow airport. Greenwald
- initially insisted it was simply the gov't applying pressure on Greenwald
- by harassing his family, lambasting the government as cruel despots, and
- didn't say anything about Miranda carrying an encrypted hard drive. You can
- still criticize the government for detaining him how they did, but lying
- about the reasons, to get an edge on defining how the news cycle talks
- about it -- that corrodes trust.
- But, you know, that's fine, that's for others to tell. CITIZENFOUR is about
- Snowden's decisions, not Greenwald's decisions, and it does a great job at
- communicating and humanizing them.
- -- Eric