From Round Marmoset, 10 Years ago, written in Plain Text.
Embed
  1. That's my memory as well. I also don't remember any cognitive dissonance
  2. between Poitras' and Greenwald's answers to Snowden's question about how
  3. much background to go into. The film doesn't portray a lot of daylight
  4. between Snowden and Greenwald in what they want to do, really.
  5.  
  6. But that's what you should expect from the movie, I think, given a) how
  7. close Poitras and Greenwald are, and b) that the movie is clearly meant to
  8. tell Snowden's story and show his motives and impact, not amplify any drama
  9. between the people involved.
  10.  
  11. The movie didn't cover, for example, Greenwald misleading the entire world
  12. on why David Miranda was detained at the Heathrow airport. Greenwald
  13. initially insisted it was simply the gov't applying pressure on Greenwald
  14. by harassing his family, lambasting the government as cruel despots, and
  15. didn't say anything about Miranda carrying an encrypted hard drive. You can
  16. still criticize the government for detaining him how they did, but lying
  17. about the reasons, to get an edge on defining how the news cycle talks
  18. about it -- that corrodes trust.
  19.  
  20. But, you know, that's fine, that's for others to tell. CITIZENFOUR is about
  21. Snowden's decisions, not Greenwald's decisions, and it does a great job at
  22. communicating and humanizing them.
  23.  
  24. -- Eric